How to Prepare for an I-9 Audit and Stay in Compliance
Access this expert-led webinar instantly, available anytime on-demand.
Included in All-Access Membership Live Webinar
On-Demand Webinar Available
Customer Satisfaction Guarantee Learn with confidence. If you're not happy, we'll make it right. That's our guarantee.
Every employer in the U.S. is legally required to maintain a complete and accurate Form I-9 for each employee hired after November 1986. However, many organizations remain unaware of the severe consequences that can arise from even minor compliance missteps. With increased scrutiny from both USCIS and ICE, employers are more at risk than ever of facing significant fines, heightened government oversight, or even criminal penalties. In this informative webinar, Fisher Phillips attorney Lauren Sobaski will break down the compliance essentials that every HR professional and business owner must know.
Lauren will walk attendees through the intricacies of properly completing Form I-9, common pitfalls that can lead to audit findings, and best practices to ensure long-term compliance. From understanding retention requirements to preparing your organization for a potential government audit, this session provides practical, actionable insights to protect your company. Don’t miss this opportunity to stay ahead of enforcement trends and build a robust compliance program that withstands federal scrutiny.
Your Benefits For Attending:- Learn how to properly complete the I-9 form to ensure compliance from day one
- Identify and avoid the most common mistakes employers make during the I-9 process
- Understand document retention requirements and timelines for I-9 forms
- Gain strategies to prepare your organization for a potential government audit
- Learn about potential liability and penalties associated with I-9 deficiencies
Attending this webinar will help you minimize legal risk and protect your organization from costly enforcement actions by ensuring you’re up to date on the latest I-9 compliance practices.
Who Would Benefit From This Webinar:- HR professionals and compliance officers
- Hiring managers and recruiters
- Business owners and executives
- Legal counsel and employment attorneys
-
Lauren M. Sobaski
Lauren Sobaski [pronounced So ba ski] is a dedicated attorney who brings a unique blend of expertise and personal experience to her practice. With a 15-year background in human resources and a master's degree in industrial-organizational psychology, Lauren has a deep understanding of human behavior [...]
ATAHR Credit
Aurora Training Advantage is offering continuing education points designed to recognize dedication to training and excellence in human resources.HRCI Credit
SHRM Credit
Invest in your future with confidence! Our Customer Satisfaction Guarantee eliminates all risk, letting you focus purely on mastering new skills and advancing your career. If you're not completely satisfied, we'll ensure you are. Your satisfaction is not just a promise; it's our guarantee.
This webinar received a total of 4 survey responses. Attendees have given an average rating of 4.7 stars out of a possible 5, reflecting the quality and value of the content presented.
Webinar Presentation
How many of the objectives of the event were met?
4.8 Stars
How useful was the information presented at this event?
4.8 Stars
Overall, how satisfied were you with this event?
4.8 Stars
Speaker Performance
Overall, how satisfied were you with this presenter?
4.8 Stars
How closely did the presenter follow the schedule?
4.5 Stars
Reviews From Webinar Survey
Our webinars are crafted to deliver exceptional value and insight to business professionals. Below, you'll find genuine feedback from attendees.
Angela J.
February 10, 2026
3.8 / 5
Webinar Rating:
4.0 Stars
Speaker Rating:
3.5 Stars
Do you have any other comments, questions or concerns?
Charlotte C.
February 10, 2026
5.0 / 5
Webinar Rating:
5.0 Stars
Speaker Rating:
5.0 Stars
Do you have any other comments, questions or concerns?
no comment
Erin F.
February 10, 2026
5.0 / 5
Webinar Rating:
5.0 Stars
Speaker Rating:
5.0 Stars
Do you have any other comments, questions or concerns?
This webinar was extremely informative, with a concise delivery of the materials, well-timed use of supporting slides and easy to follow procedures.
Karen R.
February 10, 2026
5.0 / 5
Webinar Rating:
5.0 Stars
Speaker Rating:
5.0 Stars
Do you have any other comments, questions or concerns?
no comment
Frequently Asked Questions
Every U.S. employer is legally required to complete a Form I-9 for each employee hired after November 6, 1986, to verify their identity and authorization to work in the United States. The form must be completed within three business days of the employee's first day of work: Section 1 by the employee on or before the first day, and Section 2 by the employer within three days. Common compliance mistakes include accepting documents that are not on the acceptable list, completing Section 2 before the employee has provided their documents in person, failing to reverify employment authorization when it expires, improperly completing the preparer/translator certification, and not retaining forms for the required period (three years from the date of hire or one year after employment ends, whichever is later). USCIS and ICE enforcement has intensified significantly, and even technical paperwork errors carry civil penalties—making systematic compliance processes rather than ad hoc form completion essential for any organization with meaningful hiring volume.
Preparing for a government I-9 audit requires both proactive compliance maintenance and a documented response plan for when an audit notice arrives. Proactively, organizations should conduct internal I-9 audits—ideally annually—to identify and correct technical errors before government inspection. These self-audits should review every active employee's I-9 for completeness, ensure all required reverifications have been completed for employees with temporary work authorization, and confirm that retention timelines have been applied correctly to terminated employees. Corrections must follow specific IRS guidelines: draw a single line through incorrect information, write the correct information, date and initial the correction, and never use white-out. When a Notice of Inspection (NOI) arrives from ICE, employers have three business days to produce their I-9 records—having an organized, accessible I-9 filing system is essential for meeting this deadline without error. Engaging employment counsel immediately upon receipt of an NOI and preparing a summary of the organization's compliance practices helps manage the audit process professionally and positions the organization favorably in any penalty discussions.
I-9 penalties fall into two categories: paperwork violations and substantive violations, each carrying different penalty ranges. Paperwork violations—such as missing information, incorrect document notations, or improperly completed certifications—carry civil penalties ranging from $281 to $2,789 per violation as of recent penalty adjustments. Substantive violations involving knowingly hiring or continuing to employ unauthorized workers carry significantly higher penalties, up to $27,000 per violation for repeat offenders, and can include criminal charges. The most effective liability reduction strategies include implementing a standardized I-9 completion process (using checklists and trained HR staff), conducting regular internal audits with prompt correction of identified errors, maintaining organized and accessible I-9 files separated from personnel records, and establishing a reverification tracking system to ensure timely follow-up when work authorization expires. Organizations that demonstrate good faith compliance efforts—documented policies, training records, and prompt self-correction—typically receive more favorable treatment during government audits than those with no evidence of systematic compliance management.
I-9 document retention requirements mandate that employers retain each form for the longer of three years from the date of hire or one year following the date the employee's employment ends. For active employees, this typically means retaining I-9s for the full duration of employment. For terminated employees, the calculation must be made individually: if an employee was hired in 2020 and terminated in 2022, retention is required until 2023 (one year post-termination), but if they were hired in 2021 and terminated in 2022, the three-year rule from hire date (2024) applies instead. Best practice is to organize I-9 files separately from standard personnel files—either physically in a dedicated binder or digitally in a compliant electronic system—making it easier to produce records during an audit and to purge expired forms on schedule. Creating a systematic annual calendar reminder to purge I-9s for employees whose retention period has passed reduces storage burden and eliminates the risk of inadvertently retaining forms that could be reviewed during an audit beyond the period they need to be retained.
Remote hiring created significant I-9 compliance complexity because the traditional requirement for employers to physically examine original documents in the employee's presence cannot be met when hiring is conducted remotely. During and after COVID-19, DHS introduced temporary flexibilities allowing employers to accept document inspections via video, fax, or email for remote employees, subject to deferred physical inspection when the employee enters the office. These flexibilities have since expired, and employers must now comply with the standard in-person examination requirement—though the E-Verify alternative procedure introduced in 2023 allows E-Verify-enrolled employers to remotely verify documents for remote employees under specific protocols. Electronic I-9 systems offer compliance advantages—they guide users through form completion, flag missing fields, and maintain organized digital records—but they must meet specific DHS standards for audit trails, tamper resistance, and document reproduction. Employers using electronic systems should verify their vendor's compliance with these standards and maintain system documentation demonstrating adherence. Remote and hybrid hiring practices require HR to maintain heightened vigilance around I-9 compliance to avoid the errors that increase under distributed workforce conditions.